Analysts’ disagreement, self-selection, and stock returns

    Liang Wu Affiliation
    ; Yunshen Long Affiliation
    ; Wenyue Li Affiliation
    ; Bingyan Wu Affiliation


Two ex-ante variables are introduced to characterize the analysts’ biased behavior, namely the analysts’ disagreement and self-selection in analysts’ earnings forecasts. The study investigates the impact of the analysts’ disagreement and self-selection on the stock returns. A theoretical analysis derives how the stock returns are correlated with the two variables. There are two channels through which the stocks are priced according to the analysts’ disagreement. The first one is the risk channel as the analysts’ disagreement is associated with earnings uncertainty. The stock price will be discounted before the actual earnings announcement. The second one is the optimistic bias channel. The optimistic bias channel means that the stock is overpriced if the investors do not correct the analysts’ bias. The self-selection is negatively correlated with the stock return through the optimistic bias channel as more self-selection means more optimistic bias as low forecasting values are not revealed. The empirical analysis using data from the Chinese stock market supports the theoretical conclusion.

Keyword : analysts’ disagreement, self-selection, optimistic bias, stock returns, earning forecast, uncertainty

How to Cite
Wu, L., Long, Y., Li, W., & Wu, B. (2023). Analysts’ disagreement, self-selection, and stock returns. Journal of Business Economics and Management, 24(1), 37–53.
Published in Issue
Feb 1, 2023
Abstract Views
PDF Downloads
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


Chu, J., Qin, X., & Fang, J. (2019). Margin-trading, short-selling and analysts’ forecast optimism. Management World, 1, 151–228.

Diether, K. B., Malloy, C. J., & Scherbina, A. (2002). Differences of opinion and the cross section of stock returns. Journal of Finance, 57(5), 2113–2141.

Doukas, J. A., Kim, C., & Pantzalis, C. (2006). Divergence of opinion and equity returns under different states of earnings expectations. Journal of Financial Markets, 9(3), 310–331.

Francis, J., & Soffer, L. (1997). The relative informativeness of analysts’ stock recommendations and earnings forecast revisions. Journal of Accounting Research, 35(2), 193–211.

Gharghori, P., See, Q., & Veeraraghavan, M. (2011). Difference of opinion and the cross-section of equity returns: Australian evidence. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, 19(4), 435–446.

Gilson, S. C., Healy, P. M., Noe, C. F., & Palepu, K. G. (2001). Analyst specialization and conglomerate stock breakups. Journal of Accounting Research, 39(3), 565–582.

Hu, F., & Xia, Y. (2017). Analysts’ commercial motivations and earnings forecast bias: Evidence from margin transactions. Journal of Finance and Economics, 43(07), 45–56.

Irvine, P., Simko, P. J., & Nathan, S. (2004). Asset management and affiliated analysts’ forecasts. Financial Analysts Journal, 60(3), 67–78.

Jackson, A. R. (2005). Trade generation, reputation, and sell-side analysts. Journal of Finance, 60(2), 673–717.

Leuz, C. (2003). ADRs, analysts, and accuracy: Does cross listing in the United States improve a firm’s information environment and increase market value?. Journal of Accounting Research, 41(2), 347–362.

Li, L. (2012). Can analyst’s earning forecast be the best proxy for “earnings expectations”? Nankai Management Review, 15(6), 44–50+84.

Lim, T. (2001). Rationality and analyst forecast bias. The Journal of Finance, 56(1), 369–385.

Lin, H. W., & Mcnichols, M. F. (1998). Underwriting relationships, analysts’ earnings forecasts and investment recommendations. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 25(1), 101–127.

Mcnichols, M., & O’Brien, P. C. (1997). Self-selection and analyst coverage. Journal of Accounting Research, 35, 167–199.

Miller, E. M. (1977). Risk, uncertainty, and divergence of opinion. Journal of Finance, 32(4), 1151–1168.

Mola, S., & Guidolin, M. (2009). Affiliated mutual funds and analyst optimism. Journal of Financial Economics, 93(1), 108–137.

Palmon, D., Sarath, B., & Xin, H. C. (2020). Bold stock recommendations: Informative or worthless?. Contemporary Accounting Research, 37(2), 773–801.

Scherbina, A. D. (2006). Analyst disagreement, forecast bias and stock returns. SSRN.

Silva, D., & Cerqueira, A. (2021). Does investors’ divergence of opinion affect stock mispricing?. ACRN Journal of Finance and Risk Perspectives, 10(1), 1–24.

Stickel, S. E. (1991). Common stock returns surrounding earnings forecast revisions: More puzzling evidence. Accounting Review, 66, 402–416.

Tong, S. K., Grundy, B. D., Chen, N., Huang, M., Kobayashi, T., & Titman, S. (2020). Dispersion in analysts earnings forecasts and market efficiency. International Review of Finance, 20(1), 247–260.

Varian, H. R. (1985). Divergence of opinion in complete markets: A note. Journal of Finance, 40(1), 309–317.

Wang, H., & Xu, X. (2017). A study on the optimism of recommendations on the part of security analysts in the equity private placements. Journal of Nanjing University of Audit, 14(03), 47–56.

You, J., Qiu, S., & Liu, C. (2013). “Changed face” phenomena of security analysts ‘forecasting behaviors: A reputation game model and evidences. Journal of Management Sciences in China, 16(6), 67–84.

Zhang, R., Wang, R., & Wang, S. (2017). Analysts’ revisions, fundamental analysis and future stock returns. Financial Research, 445(7), 156–174.

Zhao, L., Li, Z., & Liu, J. (2013). The managers’ preferences, the optimization in the evaluation of the investment level and the obtainment of the private information. Management World, 4, 33–47.

Zheng, S. (2019). Managerial ability and analyst optimism bias. Modern Finance and Economics-Journal of Tianjin University of Finance and Economics, 39(12), 97–110.