Operation performance measurement of public rental housing delivery by PPPS with fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation

    Jingfeng Yuan Affiliation
    ; Wei Li Affiliation
    ; Bo Xia Affiliation
    ; Yuan Chen Affiliation
    ; Mirosław J. Skibniewski Affiliation


As governments promote greatly the Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) to develop the Public Rental Housing (PRH) projects, the effective and efficient operation performance measurement should be pivotal for ensuring the success and sustainable development of these projects. Thus, this paper investigated operation performance indicators (OPIs) and measured the performance level of PRH PPP projects by fuzzy-analytic hierarchy process (AHP) comprehensive evaluation (FACE) method. Four important aspects of PRH PPP projects related to the operation performance and an evaluation indicator system of 21 OPIs from these four aspects were developed, the weights of which were calculated by using the AHP method. Based on fuzzy mathematics and the expert evaluation method, all the OPIs were quantitatively graded according to five ranks of evaluation criteria. Membership functions, weights of OPIs, and maximum membership degree principle were utilized to establish a multi-level FACE model for operation performance measurement of PRH PPP projects. One PRH PPP project of Nanjing, Jiangsu Province in China was chosen as the case study. Evaluation results were derived from the proposed model, and they generally conform to the actual situation. This study provides an effective operation performance measurement framework for PRH PPPs projects.

Keyword : public rental housing (PRH), public private partnerships (PPPs), performance measurement, fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, analytic hierarchy process (AHP)

How to Cite
Yuan, J., Li, W., Xia, B., Chen, Y., & Skibniewski, M. J. (2019). Operation performance measurement of public rental housing delivery by PPPS with fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 23(5), 328-353.
Published in Issue
Jun 26, 2019
Abstract Views
PDF Downloads
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


Abdul-Aziz, A. R., & Jahn Kassim, P. S. (2011). Objectives, success and failure factors of housing public-private partnerships in Malaysia. Habitat International, 35(1), 150-157.

Adegun, O. B., & Taiwo, A. A. (2011). Contribution and challenges of the private sector’s participation in housing in Nigeria: case study of Akure, Ondo state. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 26(4), 457-467.

Ameyaw, E. E., & Chan, A. P. C. (2015). Evaluation and ranking of risk factors in public–private partnership water supply projects in developing countries using fuzzy synthetic evaluation approach. Expert Systems with Applications, 42(12), 5102-5116.

Byun, G., & Ha, M. (2016). The factors influencing residential satisfaction by public rental housing type. Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering, 15(3), 535-542.

Chen, D., & Zheng, S. (2011). Study of PPP financing model applied in public rental housing and its pricing mechanism. Construction Economy, 4 (in Chinese).

Chen, J. F., Hsieh, H. N., & Do, Q. H. (2015). Evaluating teaching performance based on fuzzy AHP and comprehensive comprehensive evaluation approach. Applied Soft Computing, 28(C), 100-108.

Chen, J., Yang, Z., & Wang, Y. P. (2014a). The new Chinese model of public housing: a step forward or backward? Housing Studies, 29(4), 534-550.

Chen, Q., Tan, D., Peng, X., & Yang, X. (2014b). High vacancy rate of public rental housing and its diversified solution. In Proceedings of the 17th International Symposium on Advancement of Construction Management and Real Estate (pp. 417-423). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.

Chen, Y. G. (2013). Pricing mechanism and a framework of public-private partnership financing risk allocation for public rental project. Applied Mechanics & Materials, 256-259(5), 2989-2992.

Chu, H., Xu, G., Yasufuku, N., Yu, Z., Liu, P., & Wang, J. (2017). Risk assessment of water inrush in karst tunnels based on two-class fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method. Arabian Journal of Geosciences, 10(7), 179.

Density, U. (2013). Living in sustainability a case study of Hong Kong public rental housing estates. In Sustainable Building 2013 Hong Kong Regional Conference (pp. 1-8). Retrieved from

Fan, S., & Lu, J. (2014). The evaluation of construction and management situation of Chinese public housing: a case study in Harbin. In 2014 International Conference on Construction and Real Estate Management, 27-28 September, Kunming, China.

Fan, S., & Lu, J. (2015). The evaluation of construction and management situation of Chinese public housing: a case study in Harbin. In ICCREM2014: Smart Construction and Management in the Context of New Technology (pp. 1727-1735).

Feng, L., Zhu, X., & Sun, X. (2014). Assessing coastal reclamation suitability based on a fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation framework: a case study of Lianyungang, China. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 89(1-2), 102-111.

Gan, X., Zuo, J., Chang, R., Li, D., & Zillante, G. (2016a). Exploring the determinants of migrant workers’ housing tenure choice towards public rental housing: a case study in Chongqing, China. Habitat International, 58, 118-126.

Gan, X., Zuo, J., Ye, K., Li, D., Chang, R., & Zillante, G. (2016b). Are migrant workers satisfied with public rental housing? A study in Chongqing, China. Habitat International, 56, 96-102.

Gao, X., & Chen, C. (2014). Study on the financing model of the PPP in public rental housing with the accumulation fund participating in. Modern Property Management, 10, 63-66 (in Chinese).

Hsiao, S. W. (1998). Fuzzy logic based decision model for product design. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 21(2), 103-116.

Hu, X. (2011). Development of performance evaluation index system about China’s public rental housing project. In 2011 Fourth International Conference on Business Intelligence and Financial Engineering (pp. 553-557). IEEE.

Huang, Y. Q. (2012). Low-income housing in Chinese cities: policies and practices. China Quarterly, 212, 941-964.

Huang, Z., & Du, X. (2015). Assessment and determinants of residential satisfaction with public housing in Hangzhou, China. Habitat International, 47, 218-230.

Ibem, E. O., Opoko, A. P., Adeboye, A. B., & Amole, D. (2013). Performance evaluation of residential buildings in public housing estates in Ogun State, Nigeria: users’ satisfaction perspective. Frontiers of Architectural Research, 2(2), 178-190.

Ibem, E., & Aduwo, E. B. (2013). Assessment of residential satisfaction in public housing in Ogun State, Nigeria. Habitat International, 40, 163-175.

Ishiyaku, B., Rozilah, K., Harir, A. I., & Abubakar, M. A. (2014). Performance evaluation of tangible and intangible building features for sustainable public housing development in Bauchi metropolis, Nigeria. In Proceedings 7th International Real Estate Research Symposium (IRERS 2014) (pp. 29-30).

James, R. N. (2008). Impact of subsidized rental housing characteristics on metropolitan residential satisfaction. Journal of Urban Planning and Development, 134(4), 166–172.

Kablan, M. M. (2004). Decision support for energy conservation promotion: an analytic hierarchy process approach. Energy Policy, 32(10), 1151-1158.

Kagioglou, M., Cooper, R., & Aouad, G. (2001). Performance management in construction: a conceptual framework. Construction Management & Economics, 19(1), 85-95.

Kim, I. J., Kim, G. Y., & Yoon, J. (2004). Estimation of the tenants’ benefits residing in public rental housing with unit size constraint in Korea. Urban Studies, 41(8), 1521-1536.

Kim, S. S., Yang, I. H., Yeo, M. S., & Kim, K. W. (2005). Development of a housing performance evaluation model for multi-family residential buildings in Korea. Building & Environment, 40(8), 1103-1116.

Lebas, M. J. (1995). Performance measurement and performance management. International Journal of Production Economics, 41(1-3), 23-35.

Li, D., Chen, H., Hui, E. C. M., Xiao, C., Cui, Q., & Li, Q. (2014). A real option-based valuation model for privately-owned public rental housing projects in China. Habitat International, 43, 125-132.

Li, D., Chen, Y., Chen, H., Hui, E., & Guo, K. (2016a). Evaluation and optimization of the financial sustainability of public rental housing projects: a case study in Nanjing, China. Sustainability, 8(4), 330.

Li, D., Guo, K., You, J., & Hui, E. C. M. (2016b). Assessing investment value of privately-owned public rental housing projects with multiple options. Habitat International, 53, 8-17.

Li, T. H. Y., Ng, S. T., & Skitmore, M. (2013). Evaluating stakeholder satisfaction during public participation in major infrastructure and construction projects: a fuzzy approach. Automation in Construction, 29(1), 123-135.

Lin, S. (2012). The study of the low occupy rate of public rental housing based on Shanghai, Nanjing, Wuhan, Zhengzhou. Price Theories and Practices, 7, 21-22. (in Chinese).

Lin, C. L., & Tan, H. L. (2013). Performance measurement in the public sector: example of the building administration authorities in Taiwan. Journal of Management in Engineering, 30(1), 97-107.

Lin, G., & Evelyn, A. L. T. (2012). Attributes influencing the determination of building adaptation potential for public housing in Singapore: occupants’ perspectives. In ICSDC 2011: Integrating Sustainability Practices in the Construction Industry (pp. 119-128).

Liu, J., Love, P. E. D., Smith, J., Matthews, J., & Sing, C.-P. (2016). Praxis of performance measurement in public-private partnerships: moving beyond the Iron Triangle. Journal of Management in Engineering, 32(4), 04016004.

Liu, L. S., Zhang, G. Q., & Wu, H. (2011). The application of safety evaluation in coal mine heading face based on Fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation method. Advanced Materials Research, 304, 401-406.

Liu, S., & Xu, T. (2014). A mode of public rental housing based on BTO-MBS financing. In ICCREM 2014: Smart Construction and Management in the Context of New Technology (pp. 1278-1285).

Liu, T., Chan, A., & Wang, S. (2014). PPP Framework for public rental housing projects in China. In International Conference on Construction and Real Estate Management (pp. 573-581).

Luo, F. F. (2014). Study on operation and management mode of public rental housing in China, taking Shanghai City and Chongqing City for example. American Journal of Sociological Research, 4(3), 102-107.

Ma, J., & Chen, L. (2010). An AHP-FCE-Based study on green logistics performance evaluation. In ICLEM 2010: Logistics For Sustained Economic Development: Infrastructure, Information, Integration (pp. 4055-4061).

Ministry of Finance of the People’s Republic of China. (2015). The notice to facilitate the investments, construction, and operation of public rental housing by using PPP. Retrieved from

Mohit, M. A., & Azim, M. (2012). Assessment of residential satisfaction with public housing in Hulhumale’, Maldives. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 50, 756-770.

Mohit, M. A., & Nazyddah, N. (2011). Social housing programme of Selangor Zakat Board of Malaysia and housing satisfaction. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 26(2), 143-164.

Otley, D. (1999). Performance management: a framework for management control systems research. Management Accounting Research, 10(4), 363-382.

Paris, D. E., & Kangari, R. (2005). Multifamily affordable housing: residential satisfaction. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 19(2), 138-145.

Patil, S. K., & Kant, R. (2014). A fuzzy AHP-TOPSIS framework for ranking the solutions of Knowledge Management adoption in Supply Chain to overcome its barriers. Expert Systems with Applications, 41(2), 679-693.

Propersi, A., Mastrilli, G., & Gundes, S. (2012). The third sector and social housing in Italy case study of a profit and non profit public private partnership. In The International Conference of the International Society for the Third-sector Research (ISTR)-Democratization, Marketization, and the Third Sector (pp. 1-29).

Riazi, M., & Emami, A. (2018). Residential satisfaction in affordable housing: a mixed method study. Cities, 82, 1-9.

Saaty, T. L. (1980). The analytic hierarchy process. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Saaty, T. L. (1990). How to make a decision: the Analytic Hierarchy Process. European Journal of Operational Research, 48(1), 9-26.

Salleh, N. A., Yusof, N., Salleh, A. G., & Johari, N. (2011). Tenant satisfaction in public housing and its relationship with rent arrears: Majlis Bandaraya Ipoh, Perak, Malaysia. International Journal of Trade Economics & Finance, 2(1), 10-18.

Sengupta, U. (2006a). Government intervention and public–private partnerships in housing delivery in Kolkata. Habitat International, 30(3), 448-461.

Sengupta, U. (2006b). Liberalization and the privatization of public rental housing in Kolkata. Cities, 23(4), 269-278.

Shahin, A., & Poormostafa, M. (2011). Facility layout simulation and optimization: an integration of advanced quality and decision making tools and techniques. Modern Applied Science, 5(4), 95-111.

Shan, X., & Ye, X. (2013). Research on public-private financing mode of public rental housing and its selection. In 2012 International Conference on Management Science & Engineering 19th Annual Conference Proceedings (pp. 1787-1793). IEEE.

Shao, M., Liang, Q., Yan, D., Qin, H., & Xiang, J. (2014). Application of fuzzy comprehensive evaluation on COGAG power plant of performance. Journal of Power & Energy Engineering, 2(9), 29-34.

Shuai, Q., & He, Y. (2012). Comprehensive evaluation of real estate investment environment based on Fuzzy-AHP. In Proceedings of the 2012 3rd International Conference on E-Business and E-Government (Vol. 4, pp. 292-295). IEEE Computer Society.

Tiwari, M. K., & Banerjee, R. (2001). A decision support system for the selection of a casting process using analytic hierarchy process. Production Planning & Control, 12(7), 689-694.

Triantaphyllou, E., & Mann, S. H. (1995). Using the analytic hierarchy process for decision making in engineering applications: some challenges. International Journal of Industrial Engineering: Applications and Practice, 2(1), 35-44.

Van Kempen, R., & Priemus, H. (2014). Revolution in social housing in the Netherlands: possible effects of new housing policies. Urban Studies, 39(2), 237-253.

Wei, H., Liu, G., & Yong, T. (2016). Wastewater treatment evaluation for enterprises based on fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation: a case study in industrial park in Taihu Basin, China. Springerplus, 5(1), 907.

Wu, F. D., & Hu, N. L. (2011). Study on the model of safety evaluation in coal mine based on Fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation method. In Mechatronic Science, Electric Engineering and Computer (MEC), 2011 International Conference on (pp. 1671-1674). IEEE.

Xinhua Net. (2012). The public rental housing in Shanghai, Nanjing, and Wuhan experienced awkwardness; households lack incentives to rent due to high prices and inferior locations. Retrieved from

Yang, Z., & Chen, J. (2014). Housing affordability and housing policy in urban China. In Springer Briefs in Economics (pp. 15-44). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.

Yin, H., Zhao, S., & Wu, Y. (2013). Low-income groups’ housing issues research. In International Conference on Construction and Real Estate Management 2013, (pp. 658-669). Karlsruhe, Germany.

You, H., & Zhang, X. (2017). Sustainable livelihoods and rural sustainability in China: ecologically secure, economically efficient or socially equitable? Resources Conservation & Recycling, 120, 1-13.

Yu, I., Kim, K., Jung, Y., & Chin, S. (2007). Comparable performance measurement system for construction companies. Journal of Management in Engineering, 23(3), 131-139.

Yu, Y., Wu, Y., Yu, N., & Wan, J. (2012). Fuzzy comprehensive approach based on AHP and entropy combination weight for pipeline leak detection system performance evaluation. In 2012 IEEE International Systems Conference SysCon 2012 (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

Yuan, J., Guang, M., Wang, X., Li, Q., & Skibniewski, M. J. (2012a). Quantitative SWOT analysis of public housing delivery by public–private partnerships in China based on the perspective of the public sector. Journal of Management in Engineering, 28(4), 407-420.

Yuan, J., Li, W., Zheng, X., & Skibniewski, M. J. (2018). Improving operation performance of public rental housing delivery by PPPs in China. Journal of Management in Engineering, 34(4), 04018015.

Yuan, J., Wang, C., Skibniewski, M. J., & Li, Q. (2012b). Developing key performance indicators for public-private partnership projects: questionnaire survey and analysis. Journal of Management in Engineering, 28(3), 252-264.

Yuan, J., Zeng, A. Y., Skibniewski, M. J., & Li, Q. (2009). Selection of performance objectives and key performance indicators in public–private partnership projects to achieve value for money. Construction Management and Economics, 27(3), 253-270.

Yuan, J., Zheng, X., You, J., & Skibniewski, M. (2017). Identifying critical factors influencing the rents of public rental housing delivery by PPPs: the case of Nanjing. Sustainability, 9(3), 345.

Zadeh, L. A. (1965). Fuzzy sets. Information & Control, 8(3), 338-353.

Zadeh, L. A. (1975). The concept of a linguistic variable and its application to approximate reasoning. Information Sciences, 8(3), 199-249.

Zhang, D., Zou, Q., & Pang, Y. (2013). The risk management of insurance funds investing in public rental housing PPP mode - taking Shanghai public rental creditor’s projects as an example. In 2013 Sixth International Conference on Business Intelligence and Financial Engineering (pp. 268-272). IEEE.

Zhang, W., Liu, W., & Li, Y. (2003). Housings’ spatial distribution and residents’ preference on housing location in Beijing. Geographical Research, 6, 751-759 (in Chinese).

Zheng, X., Le, Y., Chan, A. P. C., Hu, Y., & Li, Y. (2016). Review of the application of social network analysis (SNA) in construction project management research. International Journal of Project Management, 34(7), 1214-1225.