Identifying and prioritizing the selection criteria of appropriate repair and maintenance methods for commercial buildings

    Jolanta Tamošaitienė   Affiliation
    ; Hadi Sarvari   Affiliation
    ; Matteo Cristofaro   Affiliation
    ; Daniel W. M. Chan   Affiliation


All buildings require Repair and Maintenance (R&M) in their life cycle period. However, if R&M activities are not carried out properly, deterioration will occur, service life of buildings will be reduced, and maintenance costs will increase. Hence, selecting the appropriate R&M methods is pivotal, especially for developing countries, such as Iran, which are featured by highly constrained resources. The present study aims to identify and prioritize the main criteria for selecting the suitable R&M methods for Commercial Buildings (CBs), which is considered as a profound challenge for the Architecture, Engineering and Construction/Facility Management (AEC/FM) industry. A total of 20 senior experts in the AEC/FM  industry and CBs in Iran were invited to participate in a Delphi survey to solicit their perceptions and opinions on the selection criteria. The total number of individual criteria identified is 16, which are further divided into five categories: human resources, flexibility and technical capability, risks, cost of maintenance, together with facilities and technology. Then, the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP) technique was applied to prioritize the identified criteria. Among the 5 main selection criteria, the cost of maintenance is the most important criterion for selecting appropriate R&M methods for CBs whereas the criterion of human resources (HR) was recognized as the least important.

Keyword : repair and maintenance, life cycle costs, fuzzy approaches, commercial buildings projects

How to Cite
Tamošaitienė, J., Sarvari, H., Cristofaro, M., & Chan, D. W. M. (2021). Identifying and prioritizing the selection criteria of appropriate repair and maintenance methods for commercial buildings. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 25(5), 413–431.
Published in Issue
Jul 16, 2021
Abstract Views
PDF Downloads
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


Abu Dabous, S., & Alkass, S. (2008). Decision support method for multi‐criteria selection of bridge rehabilitation strategy. Construction Management and Economics, 26(8), 883–893.

Alani, A. M., Tattersall, R. P., & Okoroh, M. I. (2002). Quantitative models for building repair and maintenance: a comparative case‐study. Facilities, 20(5/6), 176–189.

Al-Arjani, A. H. (2002). Type and size of project influences on number of bidders for maintenance and operation projects in Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Project Management, 20(3), 279–287.

Ali, A. S. (2009). Cost decision making in building maintenance practice in Malaysia. Journal of Facilities Management, 7(4), 298–306.

Al-Shammari, M., & Mili, M. A. (2019). Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process model for customers’ bank selection decision in the Kingdom of Bahrain. Operational Research.

Amani, N., Ali, N. M., Mohammed, A. H., & Samat, R. A. (2013). Maintenance and management of wastewater system components using the condition index system, prediction process and costs estimation. Eksploatacja i Niezawodność, 15(2), 161–168.

Amani, N., Nasly, M. A., Mohamed, A. H., & Samat, R. A. (2012). A survey on the implementation of facilities maintenance management system of building in Iran. Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering, 24(1), 85–95.

Au-Yong, C. P., Ali, A. S., Ahmad, F., & Chua, S. J. (2017). Influences of key stakeholders’ involvement in maintenance management. Property Management, 35(2), 217–231.

Bagaeen, S. (2007). Brand Dubai: the instant city; or the instantly recognizable city. International Planning Studies, 12(2), 173–197.

Bahriny, F., & Bell, S. (2020). Patterns of urban park use and their relationship to factors of quality: a case study of Tehran, Iran. Sustainability, 12(4), 1560.

Baum, A. (2009). Commercial real estate investment. Taylor & Francis.

Besiktepe, D., Ozbek, M. E., & Atadero, R. A. (2020). Identification of the criteria for building maintenance decisions in facility management: first step to developing a multi-criteria decision-making approach. Buildings, 10(9), 166.

Bevilacqua, M., & Braglia, M. (2000). The analytic hierarchy process applied to maintenance strategy selection. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 70(1), 71–83.

Bond, S. A., Hwang, S., Lin, Z., & Vandell, K. D. (2007). Marketing period risk in a portfolio context: theory and empirical estimates from the UK commercial real estate market. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 34(4), 447–461.

Boussabaine, A. H., & Kirkham, R. J. (2004). Simulation of maintenance costs in UK local authority sport centres. Construction Management and Economics, 22(10), 1011–1020.

Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101.

Chan, D. W. M., & Chan, J. H. L. (2012). Developing a performance measurement index (PMI) for target cost contracts in construction: a Delphi study. Construction Law Journal, 28(8), 590–613.

Chandrahas, Mishra, S. K., & Mahapatra, D. (2015). Maintenance strategy and decision making – AHP method. International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Studies, IV(II), 256–258.

Chang, D. Y. (1996). Applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy AHP. European Journal of Operational Research, 95(3), 649–655.

Christudason, A., Kenna, P., & Lujanen, M. (2010). Legal challenges in ensuring regular maintenance and repairs of owneroccupied apartment blocks. International Journal of Law in the Built Environment, 2(2), 178–197.

Chua, S. J. L., Ali, A. S., & Alias, A. (2014). Procurement method selection for building maintenance projects: the case of Malaysian public universities. World Journal of Engineering and Technology, 2(3), 7–13.

Dabiri, M., Oghabi, M., Sarvari, H., Sabeti, M., & Kashefi, H. (2020). A combination risk-based approach to post-earthquake temporary accommodation site selection: a case study in Iran. Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems, 17(6), 54–74.

Daibing, W., & Zeng, T. (2014). BIM in the commercial real estate project operation and maintenance management of applied research. Housing Science, 3, 17.

de Almeida, A. T. (2001). Multicriteria decision making on maintenance: spares and contracts planning. European Journal of Operational Research, 129(2), 235–241.

De Silva, N., Ranasinghe, M., & De Silva, C. R. (2012). Risk factors affecting building maintenance under tropical conditions. Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction, 17(3), 235–252.

Deng, H. (1999). Multicriteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparison. International Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 21, 215–231.

Duca, J. V., & Ling, D. C. (2020). The other (commercial) real estate boom and bust: the effects of risk premia and regulatory capital arbitrage. Journal of Banking & Finance, 112, 105317.

ElSorady, D. A., & Rizk, S. M. (2020). LEED v4.1 operations and maintenance for existing buildings and compliance assessment: Bayt Al-Suhaymi, historic Cairo. Alexandria Engineering Journal, 59(1), 519–531.

Fadavi-Ghaffari, M., Azad, A., Shariatzadeh, H., Taghizadeh, G., & Aminizadeh, S. (2017). Translation, cultural adaptation, face and content validity of the Persian version “Patient-rated wrist evaluation” (PRWE-Persian) questionnaire. Journal of Modern Rehabilitation, 11(1), 51–62.

Ferreira, C., Silva, A., de Brito, J., Dias, I. S., & Flores-Colen, I. (2021). The impact of imperfect maintenance actions on the degradation of buildings’ envelope components. Journal of Building Engineering, 33, 101571.

Flores-Colen, I., & de Brito, J. (2010). A systematic approach for maintenance budgeting of buildings façades based on predictive and preventive strategies. Construction and Building Materials, 24(9), 1718–1729.

Galar, D., Parida, A., Kumar, U., Stenström, C., & Berges, L. (2011). Maintenance metrics: a hierarchical model of balanced scorecard. In 2011 IEEE International Conference on Quality and Reliability (pp. 67–74). IEEE.

Geltner, D., Miller, N. G., Clayton, J., & Eichholtz, P. (2001). Commercial real estate analysis and investments (Vol. 1).

Ghazali, Z., Lim, M. R. T., & Jamak, A. B. S. (2019). Maintenance performance improvement analysis using fuzzy Delphi method: a case of an international lube blending plant in Malaysia. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 25(1), 162–180.

Ghent, A. C., Torous, W. N., & Valkanov, R. I. (2019). Commercial real estate as an asset class. Annual Review of Financial Economics, 11, 153–171.

Ghosh, D., & Roy, S. (2010). A decision-making framework for process plant maintenance. European Journal of Industrial Engineering, 4(1), 78–98.

Grussing, M. N. (2014). Life cycle asset management methodologies for buildings. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 20(1), 04013007.

Häkkinen, T., & Belloni, K. (2011). Barriers and drivers for sustainable building. Building Research & Information, 39(3),

Hauashdh, A., Jailani, J., & Rahman, I. A. (2020). Building maintenance practices in Malaysia: a systematic review of issues, effects and the way forward. International Journal of Building Pathology and Adaptation, 38(5), 653–672.

Hon, C. K. H., Chan, A. P. C., & Chan, D. W. M. (2011). Strategies for improving safety performance of repair, maintenance, minor alteration and addition (RMAA) works. Facilities, 29(13/14), 591–610.

Hon, C. K. H., Chan, A. P. C., & Yam, M. C. H. (2012). Empirical study to investigate the difficulties of implementing safety practices in the repair and maintenance sector in Hong Kong. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 138(7), 877–884.

Hsu, C. C., & Sandford, B. A. (2007). The Delphi technique: making sense of consensus. Practical Assessment, Research, and Evaluation, 12(1), 10.

Johnson, E. (2013). Face validity. In F. R. Volkmar (Ed.), Encyclopedia of autism spectrum disorders. Springer.

Katebi, A., & Almasian, F. (2016). Review of maintenance strategies in construction projects [Conference presentation]. Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture and Structures, Norway.

Khoshfetrat, R., Sarvari, H., Chan, D. W. M., & Rakhshanifar, M. (2020). Critical risk factors for implementing building information modelling (BIM): a Delphi-based survey. International Journal of Construction Management, 1–10.

Khosravi, M., Sarvari, H., Chan, D. W. M., Cristofaro, M., & Chen, Z. (2020). Determining and assessing the risks of commercial and recreational complex building projects in developing countries: a survey of experts in Iran. Journal of Facilities Management, 18(3), 259–282.

Kim, S., Jang, Y., Shin, Y., & Kim, G. (2014). Economic feasibility analysis of the application of geothermal energy facilities to public building structures. Sustainability, 6(4), 1667–1685.

Kizim, A. V. (2013). Establishing the maintenance and repair body of knowledge: comprehensive approach to ensuring equipment maintenance and repair organization efficiency. Original Research Article Procedia Technology, 9, 812–818.

Lai, J. H. (2010). Operation and maintenance budgeting for commercial buildings in Hong Kong. Construction Management and Economics, 28(4), 415–427.

Lai, J. H. (2011). Comparative evaluation of facility management services for housing estates. Habitat International, 35, 391–397.

Lai, J. H. (2015). Maintenance performance: examination of the computer-aided maintenance data of a large commercial building. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 29(4), 4014118.

Lai, J. H., & Man, C. S. (2017). Developing a performance evaluation scheme for engineering facilities in commercial buildings: state-of-the-art review. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 21(1), 41–57.

Lai, J. H., & Man, C. S. (2018a). Performance indicators for facilities operation and maintenance (Part 1): systematic classification and mapping. Facilities, 36(9/10), 476–494.

Lai, J. H., & Man, C. S. (2018b). Performance indicators for facilities operation and maintenance (Part 2): shortlisting through a focus group study. Facilities, 36(9/10), 495–509.

Lai, J. H., Yik, F. W., & Chan, A. K. (2009). Maintenance cost of chiller plants in Hong Kong. Building Services Engineering Research and Technology, 30(1), 65–78.

Lai, J. H., Yik, F. W., & Jones, P. (2004). Disputes arising from vaguely defined contractual responsibilities in building services maintenance contracts. Facilities, 22(1/2), 44–52.

Lai, J. H., Yik, F. W., & Jones, P. (2006). Critical contractual issues of outsourced operation and maintenance service for commercial buildings. International Journal of Service Industry Management, 17(4), 320–343.

Lai, J., Yik, F., & Jones, P. (2008). Expenditure on operation and maintenance service and rental income of commercial buildings. Facilities, 26(5/6), 242–265.

Lam, E. W. M., Chan, A. P. C., & Chan, D. W. M. (2010). Benchmarking success of building maintenance projects. Facilities, 28(5/6), 290–305.

Lateef, O. A. (2009). Building maintenance management in Malaysia. Journal of Building Appraisal, 4(3), 207–214.

Lavy, S., & Bilbo, D. L. (2009). Facilities maintenance management practices in large public schools, Texas. Facilities,
27(1/2), 5–20.

Lavy, S., & Shohet, I. M. (2004). Integrated maintenance management of hospital buildings: a case study. Construction Management and Economics, 22(1), 25–34.

Lavy, S., & Shohet, I. M. (2007). On the effect of service life conditions on the maintenance costs of healthcare facilities. Construction Management and Economics, 25(10), 1087–1098.

Ledford, A. K., & Lynch, S. M. (2019). Comparing theories of resource distribution: the case of Iran. Socius, 5.

Lee, C. K., & Kim, S. K. (2007). GA-based algorithm for selecting optimal repair and rehabilitation methods for reinforced concrete (RC) bridge decks. Automation in Construction, 16(2), 153–164.

Lee, H. H. Y., & Scott, D. (2009). Overview of maintenance strategy, acceptable maintenance standard and resources from a building maintenance operation perspective. Journal of Building Appraisal, 4(4), 269–278.

Liddle, J., Bowser, J., Ilic, B., & Luciani, V. (2020). So, you want to have a NanoFab? Shared-use nanofabrication and characterization facilities: cost-of-ownership, toolset, utilization, and lessons learned. Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, 125, 125009.

Lind, H., & Muyingo, H. (2012). Building maintenance strategies: planning under uncertainty. Property Management, 30(1), 14–28.

López, J., Pérez, D., Paz, E., & Santana, A. (2013). A building maintenance and surveillance system based on autonomous robots. Robotics and Autonomous Systems, 61(12), 1559–1571.

Mangano, G., & De Marco, A. (2014). The role of maintenance and facility management in logistics: a literature review. Facilities, 32(5/6), 241–255.

Martínez, L. B., Márquez, A. C., Gunckel, P. V., & Andreani, A. A. (2013). The graphical analysis for maintenance management method: a quantitative graphical analysis to support maintenance management decision making. Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 29(1), 77–87.

Mirza, S. (2006). Durability and sustainability of infrastructure a state-of-the-art report. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 33(6), 639–649.

Motamed, P., & Majrouhi, J. (2018). A framework to select the best strategy for Iran’s entry into the repair and maintenance market of oil drilling rigs. Civil Engineering Journal, 4(11), 2702–2718.

Motawa, I., & Almarshad, A. (2013). A knowledge-based BIM system for building maintenance. Automation in Construction, 29, 173–182.

Munir, M., Kiviniemi, A., Finnegan, S., & Jones, S. W. (2019). BIM business value for asset owners through effective asset information management. Facilities, 38(3/4), 181–200.

Nourelfath, M., Nahas, N., & Ben-Daya, M. (2016). Integrated preventive maintenance and production decisions for imperfect processes. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 148, 21–31.

Olanrewaju, A. L., & Abdul-Aziz, A. R. (2014). Building maintenance processes and practices: the case of a fast developing country. Springer.

Olawumi, T. O., & Chan, D. W. M. (2018). Identifying and prioritizing the benefits of integrating BIM and sustainability practices in construction projects: a Delphi survey of international experts. Sustainable Cities and Society, 40, 16–27.

Oprea, L., & Popescu, V. (2008). Challenges and methodologies in transmission planning for mega-cities. In MELECON 2008 – The 14th IEEE Mediterranean Electrotechnical Conference (pp. 726–731). IEEE.

Ottoman, G. R., Nixon, W. B., & Lofgren, S. T. (1999). Budgeting for facility maintenance and repair. I: methods and models. Journal of Management in Engineering, 15(4), 71–83.

Parida, A., & Chattopadhyay, G. (2007). Development of a multicriteria hierarchical framework for maintenance performance measurement (MPM). Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 13(3), 241–258.

Pezshki, Z. M., Shadman, A., Alizadeh, M., Hakimi, S., & Heidari, F. (2017). Validity and reliability of the questionnaire for assessing women’s reproductive history in Azar cohort study. Journal of Caring Sciences, 6(2), 185–188.

Pivo, G., & Fisher, J. D. (2011). The walkability premium in commercial real estate investments. Real Estate Economics, 39(2), 185–219.

Pourjavad, E., Shirouyehzad, H., & Shahin, A. (2013). Selecting maintenance strategy in mining industry by analytic network process and TOPSIS. International Journal of Industrial and Systems Engineering, 15(2), 171–192.

Preedy, V. R. (2010). Content validity. In V. R. Preedy, & Watson, R. R. (Eds.), Handbook of disease burdens and quality of life measures. Springer.

Re Cecconi, F., Moretti, N., & Dejaco, M. C. (2019). Measuring the performance of assets: a review of the facility condition index. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 23(3), 187–196.

Ruparathna, R., Hewage, K., & Sadiq, R. (2018). Multi-period maintenance planning for public buildings: a risk-based approach for climate conscious operation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 170, 1338–1353.

Saaty, T. L. (1972). An eigenvalue allocation model for prioritization and planning. Energy management and policy center (Working paper, pp. 28–31). University of Pennsylvania.

Sadeghi, M., Elliott, J. W., Porro, N., & Strong, K. (2019). Developing building information models (BIM) for building handover, operation and maintenance. Journal of Facilities Management, 17(3), 301–316.

Sayed, A. Y. A., Seth, D., & Hamouda, A. M. S. (2019). Prioritisation of lean construction barriers in Qatari context: a fuzzy AHP approach. International Journal of Business Excellence, 19(4), 503–531.

Sarvari, H., Chan, D. W. M., Banaitiene, N., Noor, N. M., & Beer, M. (2021). Barriers to development of private sector investment in water and sewage industry. Built Environment Project and Asset Management, 11(1), 52–70.

Sarvari, H., Cristofaro, M., Chan, D. W. M., Noor, N. M., & Amini, M. (2020). Completing abandoned public facility projects by the private sector: results of a Delphi survey in the Iranian Water and Wastewater Company. Journal of Facilities Management, 18(5), 547–566.

Sarvari, H., Rakhshanifar, M., Tamošaitienė, J., Chan, D. W. M., & Beer, M. (2019). A risk based approach to evaluating the impacts of Zayanderood drought on sustainable development indicators of riverside urban in Isfahan-Iran. Sustainability, 11(23), 6797.

Shafiee, M. (2015). Maintenance strategy selection problem: an MCDM overview. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 21(4), 378–402.

Shen, G. Q. P. (1997). A comparative study of priority setting methods for planned maintenance of public buildings. Facilities, 15(12/13), 331–339.

Shyjith, K., Ilangkumaran, M., & Kumanan, S. (2008). Multi‐criteria decision‐making approach to evaluate optimum maintenance strategy in textile industry. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 14(4), 375–386.

Shohet, I. M. (2003). Building evaluation methodology for setting maintenance priorities in hospital buildings. Construction Management and Economics, 21(7), 681–692.

Shohet, I. M., & Nobili, L. (2016a). Performance-based maintenance of public facilities: principles and implementation in courthouses. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 30(4), 04015086.

Shohet, I. M., & Nobili, L. (2016b). Enterprise resource planning system for performance-based-maintenance of clinics.
Automation in Construction, 65, 33–41.

Shohet, I. M., & Nobili, L. (2017). Application of key performance indicators for maintenance management of clinics facilities. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 21(1), 58–71.

Shohet, I. M., & Perelstein, E. (2004). Decision support model for the allocation of resources in rehabilitation projects. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 130(2), 249–257.

Shohet, I. M., & Straub, A. (2013). Performance-based-maintenance: a comparative study between the Netherlands and Israel. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 17(2), 199–209.

Shohet, I. M., Lavy-Leibovich, S., & Bar-On, D. (2003). Integrated maintenance monitoring of hospital buildings. Construction Management and Economics, 21(2), 219–228.

Sodangi, M., Khamdi, M. F., Idrus, A., Hammad, D. B., & AhmedUmar, A. (2014). Best practice criteria for sustainable maintenance management of heritage buildings in Malaysia. Procedia Engineering, 77, 11–19.

Straub, A. (2002). Strategic technical management of housing stock: lessons from Dutch housing associations. Building Research and Information, 30(5), 372–381.

Suganthi, L. (2018). Multi expert and multi criteria evaluation of sectoral investments for sustainable development: an integrated fuzzy AHP, VIKOR/DEA methodology. Sustainable Cities and Society, 43, 144–156.

Suweero, K., Moungnoi, W., & Charoenngam, C. (2017). Outsourcing decision factors of building operation and maintenance services in the commercial sector. Property Management, 35(3), 254–274.

Taber, K. S. (2018). The use of Cronbach’s alpha when developing and reporting research instruments in science education. Research in Science Education, 48, 1273–1296.

Tamošaitienė, J., Sarvari, H., Chan, D. W. M., & Cristofaro, M. (2021). Assessing the barriers and risks to private sector participation in infrastructure construction projects in developing countries of Middle East. Sustainability, 13(1), 153.

Thaheem, M. J., & De Marco, A. (2014). Sustainable repair & maintenance of buildings in the developing countries: a risk management perspective and proposal of customized framework. Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture Research, 1(1), 14–23.

Thengane, S. K. (2019). Assessment of different technologies for managing yard waste using analytic hierarchy process. Process Integration and Optimization for Sustainability, 3, 255–272.

United Nations. (2020). World economic situation prospects.

Vanier, D., Tesfamariam, S., Sadiq, R., & Lounis, Z. (2006, June 14–16). Decision models to prioritize maintenance and renewal alternatives. In Joint International Conference on Computing and Decision Making in Civil and Building Engineering (pp. 2594–2603), Montréal, QC.

Wall, D. M. (1993). Building maintenance in the context of developing countries. Construction Management and Economics, 11(3), 186–193.

Wieczorek, D., Plebankiewicz, E., & Zima, K. (2019). Model estimation of the whole life cost of a building with respect to risk factors. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 25(1), 20–38.

Yousefli, Z., Nasiri, F., & Moselhi, O. (2020). Maintenance workflow management in hospitals: an automated multi-agent facility management system. Journal of Building Engineering, 32, 101431.

Yuan, J., Li, W., Xia, B., Chen, Y., & Skibniewski, M. J. (2019). Operation performance measurement of public rental housing delivery by PPPS with fuzzy-AHP comprehensive evaluation. International Journal of Strategic Property Management, 23(5), 328–353.

Zavadskas, E. K., Turskis, Z., & Kildienė, S. (2014). State of art surveys of overviews on MCDM/MADM methods. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 20, 165–179.

Zawawi, E. M. A., & Kamaruzzaman, S. N. (2009). Personnel characteristics of maintenance practice: a case of high-rise office buildings in Malaysia. Journal of Sustainable Development, 2(1), 111.